Back to FluxBenchFluxBench checked September 23, 2026

FluxBench.AI

How FluxBench compares

A browser workbench for firmware, circuits and hardware design. See what works today, where specialist tools set the benchmark, and what we plan to improve next.

Selected benchmarks by workflow, based on official vendor documentation and FluxBench source and recorded tests. These are our comparison choices, not an independent market ranking. No head-to-head usability or accuracy study has been completed. Targets are planned work, not shipped capabilities.

Board support and reproducible Lab references

Lab first

CRUMB for 3D interaction; Wokwi for firmware execution and test automation.

A guided software path

Cirkit Designer for browser onboarding; separate simulation, compilation and physical test results.

Software work first

Physical controllers and all PCB work are deferred until the remaining software roadmap is exhausted.

3D breadboard

L1 - software delivered; comparisons pending

CRUMB

3D circuit construction, an 830-point breadboard, interactive parts and pin labels. Desktop and mobile versions have different feature sets.

Sources: 1

FluxBench today

Shared 2D/3D editing, live controls and displays, whole-net tracing, named-terminal wiring, Undo and project recovery are implemented. A two-hour local session with 40 parts and 56 wires passed its declared stability checks.

That graphics/stability result covers one browser/GPU setup. Additional devices and comparative usability remain unmeasured.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Complete the same build, trace, edit and recovery tasks at least 20% faster than CRUMB, without more wiring errors; retain browser access.

Lab measurements

L1 - bounded software checks delivered

CRUMB + Wokwi

CRUMB documents voltage/current views and oscilloscopes. Wokwi documents a digital logic analyzer and automated pin/serial assertions.

Sources: 1, 2, 4

FluxBench today

Shared 2D/3D probes, simulation-time GPIO/serial capture, timestamped CSV, triggers, cursors and saved input/fault scenarios are implemented. Failed checks link captured observations to circuit locations. Compiled Uno adds timed ADXL345 X/Y orientations, eight new firmware cases and backend-aware scenario editing.

Teaching scenarios use an approximate Arduino subset with duty-averaged PWM. Separate compiled Uno captures and the analog SPICE bench have their own declared limits. Diagnostic hints do not establish code causality.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Broaden independently validated sensor/device scenarios and measure the published reference tasks against CRUMB/Wokwi.

Firmware simulation

L2 - Uno and bounded Pico captures; broader scope open

Wokwi

Supported MCU firmware across AVR, ARM, RISC-V and Xtensa, with CI execution. Automation scenarios are labeled alpha.

Sources: 2, 3, 4

FluxBench today

Opt-in compiled Uno and original-Pico captures connect firmware to circuit inputs, checks and shared 2D/3D probes. Pico includes a 38-case ADXL345 gate, an 89-case MCP3008 gate, a 123-case sensor/display pair gate, 204 display-history cases and 59 ultrasonic parking cases and 47 prepowered DHT22 cases. Counts include positive and expected-refusal cases. Thirteen saved examples cover timing, inputs and fault recovery. OLED memory and ultrasonic pulses follow the capture cursor; missing display bytes remain unknown. DHT scenarios distinguish changed inputs, faults and cached driver reads.

Teaching stays the default. Uno requests up to five seconds; Pico up to 500 ms at 125 MHz with fixed budgets and independent host services, without vendor ROM. The only qualified sensor/display combination is ADXL345 plus SSD1306. Stock Adafruit graphics use a separate memory profile with unmodeled initialization; HC-SR04 uses a separate ideal pulse/divider profile. DHT22 uses a separate prepowered profile with pinned library and ideal DC wiring. Cold startup, physical sensor accuracy, acoustic accuracy, full OLED power-up/optical behavior, other device combinations, PIO, multicore and USB Serial remain unqualified. ESP32 has no accepted compiled backend.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Qualify useful sensor/display combinations and additional named device/library cases. Broader MCU coverage and independent Wokwi task comparisons remain open.

Guided browser workflow

L3 - software delivered; participant pilot pending

Cirkit Designer

AI wiring/code, Arduino/ESP32/Pico simulation, custom components and browser upload are documented in one workflow.

Sources: 5

FluxBench today

The parking software guide has six repeatable checks with 43 GPIO/serial expectations, sensor-loss recovery and a compile/save/reopen finish. It can be completed without a physical controller.

Beginner and competitor timing studies remain pending. The displayed 15 minutes is an estimate; the tilt guide waits for the parking participant gate.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Four of five newcomers complete the parking simulation unaided within 15 minutes; median task time at least 20% below Cirkit with no higher error rate.

Compile and USB upload

H1 - physical work deferred

Arduino Cloud + Cirkit

Arduino Cloud uses its installed Agent for USB upload. Cirkit documents browser upload for supported Arduino, ESP32 and Pico boards.

Sources: 6, 5

FluxBench today

Cloud compilation is separately verified across sixteen core configurations. The Windows local compiler preview has four pinned board packages and eleven build cases, explicit Cloud / This computer selection, installed-version checks and stalled-request recovery. ESP32 Web Serial flashing, a serial monitor/plotter and board-specific guides exist.

Local failures never automatically submit to cloud. Public HTTPS-to-loopback, fresh-user installation, signing and non-Windows packaging remain acceptance gates. Compile, simulate and upload coverage differ; new physical ESP32/Uno/Pico validation is deferred.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Keep compile, simulation and upload evidence separate. Resume physical upload/reboot/serial checks after the remaining software roadmap and owner resumption.

Analog and mixed simulation

A1 - bounded analog and mixed-reference software delivered

KiCad/ngspice + Proteus

KiCad offers ngspice analysis; Proteus co-simulates supported MCU code with mixed-mode circuits. EasyEDA Pro 3.2+ has circuit simulation, excluding MCU code co-simulation.

Sources: 7, 8, 9

FluxBench today

An independent ngspice 47 bench provides DC/transient/AC analysis, twenty-one checked examples including ideal RL/RLC, seven frequency references and six DC characteristic sweeps, signed currents, complex gain/phase, frequency cursors and SPICE/CSV files. Ten R/C breadboard snapshots and twenty AC/DC sweep variants preserve connectivity, show their test stimulus and detect stale wiring. A separate qualified Uno/RC example adds a 250 µs source-bound capture with compiled firmware and native analog input crossings.

The mixed example accepts one exact sketch and a 10 kΩ / 1 nF INT1 circuit with behavioral thresholds. Other mixed circuits, silicon accuracy and manufacturer models are unqualified. The investigated LM358 macro was rejected; generic netlists are not manufacturer validation.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Preserve the qualified numerical/timing subsets, qualify newly selected models with independent tests, and measure equivalent KiCad/Proteus tasks before claiming an advantage.

Schematic and PCB

P1 - all PCB work deferred

KiCad + EasyEDA + Flux

Established schematic/layout/export workflows; Flux documents AI placement/routing and live sourcing. Feature coverage varies by product and edition.

Sources: 10, 11, 12

FluxBench today

ERC/DRC, layout/routing, fabrication exports and part-specific checks exist. A five-board ESP32 prototype review package is prepared.

All PCB work is deferred until the remaining software roadmap is exhausted and the owner resumes it. No supplier submission, quote or prototype order is recorded.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

After resumption, resolve supplier review, separately approve prototypes and validate the resulting hardware before production claims.

AI and reusable parts

AI1 - bounded software gates delivered

Flux + Cirkit Designer

Flux documents AI design reviews, datasheet work and live parts data. Cirkit documents custom visuals, pin definitions and AI-generated simulation behavior.

Sources: 12, 5

FluxBench today

The fixed twenty-task evaluation passed 20/20 after a 19/20 baseline. Eight sketches compiled and passed runtime checks; wiring/editor changes support guarded recovery. Ten reusable records preserve 25 pins and 300 connectivity pairs through native round trips. A live owner-account check also preserved ten synthetic records through cloud import, reload and exact export, followed by cleanup. Individual companion pairing is software-verified.

These are bounded tests, not manufacturer-model qualification or a competitor win. The cloud check started with an empty library, so it does not establish legacy-data recovery. Another-user companion acceptance, complete cost reconciliation and comparative measurements remain pending.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Verify independent companion acceptance, then run equivalent fixed tasks against Flux/Cirkit with model, attempts, time and cost recorded.

FPGA and HDL

F1 - ten software references delivered

EDA Playground

Verilog/SystemVerilog, VHDL and multiple simulators/synthesis tools. Some commercial tools require validated access.

Sources: 13

FluxBench today

A published tool matrix and ten HDL designs pass 40 testbench assertions, 40 waveform samples, repeat agreement, ten injected faults and synthesis. The viewer preserves 64-bit values and exposes a capture-time cursor.

This is a bounded Verilog-oriented Icarus/Yosys subset. VHDL, UVM, full SystemVerilog and commercial simulator parity are not established. Physical FPGA validation remains deferred.

Evidence and scope

Target - planned

Measure the tested waveform/debugging tasks against EDA Playground. Add language/tool breadth only for a real project and a reviewed compatibility gate.

Sources and scope

Vendor sources were reviewed on September 20, 2026; FluxBench software evidence was updated on September 23, 2026 and is pinned to the reviewed version. Documented features are not proof of equal accuracy, performance or ease of use. Board, edition and platform restrictions apply. Personal Codex requires the owner's desktop companion; USB flashing requires a compatible browser and board.

Public guides: analog Lab and examples · HDL tools and waveforms. Detailed repository evidence requires repository access.

  1. CRUMB: released features by version
  2. Wokwi: supported hardware
  3. Wokwi: CI and GitHub Actions
  4. Wokwi: automation scenarios (alpha)
  5. Cirkit Designer: workflow and custom parts
  6. Arduino: official Cloud Agent repository
  7. KiCad: ngspice simulation
  8. Proteus: VSM simulation
  9. EasyEDA Pro: simulation scope
  10. KiCad: product scope
  11. EasyEDA: edition features
  12. Flux: AI, PCB and manufacturing workflow
  13. EDA Playground: languages and tools
FluxBench.AI comparison and development targets